Choosing AirPods: Which Generation Is Right for You?
Six years of AirPods. From the laughable white sticks to a status symbol. You want new earbuds, but which generation should you choose? The first generation for next to nothing? The third with spatial audio? Or perhaps the Pro with noise canceling? The AirPods collection has become a maze of choices.
But here's what Apple doesn't tell you: the latest generation isn't automatically the best buy. In fact, for most users, the very latest technology is a complete waste of money. The differences between generations are often subtle, the price differences are not. And those fancy features you pay extra for? You probably never use them.
This article reveals which generation truly suits your needs – without the marketing hype. Plus: why refurbished accessories can save you hundreds of euros without compromise.
Useful links
- Refurbished AirPods Pro 2 collection
- All refurbished AirPods models
- iPhone collection for perfect pairing
The evolution of wireless freedom
The development of AirPods demonstrates how quickly technology evolves. From the first generation in 2016 to the latest Pro 2 today, each step has brought improvements that aren't always visible, but are certainly noticeable in use. It started with skepticism about the white sticks, but now they're an indispensable part of everyday life.
Generation 1: The Foundation That Changed Everything
The first generation introduced the W1 chip and the iconic charging case. With five hours of listening time and 24 hours total with the case, they were revolutionary for their time. Their seamless pairing with Apple devices made them instantly popular, despite limited fit adjustments.
First generation specifications:
- W1 chip for fast connection
- 5 hours of listening time
- 24 hours with charging case
- Double tap to activate Siri
- Automatic ear detection
Generation 2: Refinement without revolution
In 2019, the second model, featuring the H1 chip, arrived. This upgrade brought 50% more talk time, faster device connections, and hands-free "Hey Siri" functionality. The optional wireless charging case was a welcome addition for users with wireless chargers at home.
Second generation improvements:
- H1 chip for better efficiency
- 30% lower latency in gaming
- Hands-free Siri activation
- Optional wireless charging case
- Improved call quality
Generation 3: the best of both worlds
The 2021 third generation borrowed the design of the Pro models while retaining their accessible price. With six hours of listening time and 30 hours total, they took a leap forward. Spatial audio and adaptive EQ brought premium features to the entry-level model.
New features third generation:
- Spatial audio with dynamic head tracking
- Adaptive EQ for personal tuning
- IPX4 sweat and water resistance
- MagSafe wireless charging
- Pressure sensor for operation
The shorter stem design makes them more compact, although some users miss the longer stem for holding onto when inserting and removing.
AirPods Pro: for the demanding listener
The Pro line is aimed at users who want the ultimate in performance. With active noise cancellation, transparency mode, and interchangeable eartips, they adapt to any situation. The first Pro from 2019 set the standard, but the 4.5-hour battery life was a compromise.
Pro features:
- Active noise cancellation (ANC)
- Transparency mode for situational awareness
- Three sizes of silicone earplugs
- Ventilation opening for pressure relief
- Customizable sound settings
AirPods Pro 2: the current top
The second-generation Pro doubled the noise cancellation and introduced adaptive transparency. This smart mode filters out loud noises like sirens while allowing conversations to pass through. With six hours of listening time and touch controls on the stem, they're the most complete option.
Pro 2 upgrades:
- H2 chip for advanced processing
- Up to 2x better noise suppression
- Adaptive transparency mode
- Volume control via swipe gestures
- Personalized spatial audio
- Extra small earplugs (XS)
Which one suits your use?
Occasional listening: The second generation offers the best value for money. For calls, podcasts, and background music, they're more than adequate.
Sporty user: Generation 3 with IPX4 protection and a better fit is ideal for training. The shorter stems get in the way less.
Commuting professional: The Pro 2 with superior noise cancellation makes trains and planes bearable. The extended battery life supports a workday.
Music lover: Here too, the Pro 2 wins thanks to its customizable sound settings and high-quality drivers.
Refurbished: the smart choice
New earbuds are expensive, especially the Pro models. Refurbished models offer the same quality for considerably less money. They're professionally cleaned, tested, and fitted with new batteries where necessary. With a warranty and return policy, you run no risk.
The price differences are significant: while new Pro 2 earbuds cost around €279, refurbished versions start at €200. For older generations, this difference can reach up to 40%.
Practical considerations
Battery life remains the most significant difference between generations. The change from five to six hours seems small, but in practice, it makes the difference between charging during lunch and working all day.
The fit varies by model. Regular versions are one size fits all, while the Pro line offers a variety of options. Try different sizes whenever possible – a good seal is essential for sound quality and comfort.
Android compatibility is possible, but limited. Features like automatic device switching, battery percentage display, and spatial audio only work within the Apple ecosystem.
Choosing future-proof
The latest generation is tempting, but consider your actual needs. For most users, the third generation is more than sufficient. The price difference compared to the Pro 2 is better spent on a good protective case or AppleCare+.
Software updates continue for years for all generations. Apple typically provides support for five years after its introduction, so even the second generation will continue to receive updates until 2024.
The choice between generations ultimately comes down to priorities: do you want the best sound quality, longest battery life, or the best deal? With refurbished options, you have to make fewer compromises – premium features are available without premium prices.
The right choice without marketing talk
The AirPods evolution shows that newer doesn't automatically mean better for your situation. The second generation is sufficient for everyday use, the third offers the best balance between price and performance, while the Pro 2 is only worth its price premium for intensive use in noisy environments.
With refurbished models, you get the same quality for less money—a wise choice in a market where technology quickly becomes outdated but functionality lasts for years. Choose based on your actual needs , not on the latest model.
